By Destrée, P. (ed.), Bobonich, Ch. (ed.), Christopher Bobonich, Pierre Destree

The thirteen contributions of this collective supply new and not easy methods of examining famous and extra overlooked texts on akrasia (lack of keep an eye on, or weak point of will) in Greek philosophy (Socrates, Plato, Aristotle, the Stoics, Plotinus).

Show description

Read or Download Akrasia in Greek Philosophy (Philosophia Antiqua) PDF

Best greek & roman books

Essays in ancient Greek philosophy, Volume 3

Publication via Anton, John P.

The Other Plato: The Tubingen Interpretation of Plato's Inner-academic Teachings

Supplying a provocative replacement to the dominant methods of Plato scholarship, the Tübingen institution means that the dialogues don't inform the complete tale of Plato’s philosophical teachings. Texts and fragments through his scholars and their followers—most famously Aristotle’s Physics—point to an “unwritten doctrine” articulated by means of Plato on the Academy.

Levinas and the ancients

The relation among the Greek and Judeo-Christian traditions is "the nice challenge" of Western philosophy, in line with Emmanuel Levinas. during this booklet Brian Schroeder, Silvia Benso, and a world workforce of philosophers tackle the connection among Levinas and the realm of old suggestion. as well as philosophy, subject matters bearing on faith, mythology, metaphysics, ontology, epistemology, ethics, and politics also are explored.

The Returns of Odysseus: Colonization and Ethnicity

This remarkably wealthy and multifaceted examine of early Greek exploration makes an unique contribution to present discussions of the encounters among Greeks and non-Greeks. Focusing specifically on myths approximately Odysseus and different heroes who visited international lands on their legendary voyages homeward after the Trojan conflict, Irad Malkin exhibits how those tales functioned to mediate encounters and conceptualize ethnicity and id throughout the Archaic and Classical classes.

Additional resources for Akrasia in Greek Philosophy (Philosophia Antiqua)

Example text

3. An Objection Considered At this point someone might object that if our view were correct, Socrates would have no reason to refer to moral knowledge as the metrêtikê technê, the craft of measurement. It is clear in the Protagoras that Socrates thinks that moral knowledge judges appearances. It objectively ‘measures’ each and it ‘saves’ us by preventing us from being taken in by the power of appearance. But, so the objection goes, according to our view, Socratic knowledge is incompatible with strong nonrational desire and yet it is strong nonrational desire that makes objects appear to be good when they are not.

4. Socrates, Plato, and Aristotle As we have seen, Devereux argues that Socrates’ moral psychology is importantly different from that of either Plato or Aristotle. Socrates disagrees with his successors over the possibility that virtue can exist together with strong, nonrational desire. According to Devereux, Socrates thinks they are compatible; Plato and Aristotle did not. Although we disagree with Devereux about this particular aspect of Socrates’ moral psychology, we nonetheless agree with him that there is an important difference between Socrates’ view, on the one hand, and those of Plato and Aristotle, on the other.

This is, I suppose, what Thomas C. Brickhouse and Nicholas Smith (2002) have called—somewhat puzzlingly: see the second paragraph of this note—‘the traditional account of Socratic intellectualism’ (22). 11 Once properly understood (especially with the help of the Lysis), intellectualism is revealed as key to the proper appreciation of the argumentation of a range of dialogues that includes the Symposium (and indeed other traditional ‘middle’ dialogues). Yet in Book IV of the Republic Socrates seems specifically to reject intellectualism,12 and numerous other dialogues clearly imply its rejection.

Download PDF sample

Akrasia in Greek Philosophy (Philosophia Antiqua) by Destrée, P. (ed.), Bobonich, Ch. (ed.), Christopher
Rated 4.99 of 5 – based on 31 votes